Most owners know how much their property brought in. Far fewer know how much they have left. Working out the profitability of a short-term rental takes method, because this way of operating combines irregular income with far more costs than conventional letting. Here is the approach we apply with owners on the Opal Coast, step by step.
Three indicators never to be confused
Gross yield relates annual income to the purchase price of the property, fees included. It is useful for quickly comparing two opportunities, and nothing more. It ignores all your costs and systematically flatters short-term letting.
Net yield deducts all operating and ownership costs. It is the only indicator that describes the asset’s real performance.
Cash flow measures what comes into and goes out of your account each month, loan repayment and tax included. A property can show a respectable net yield and negative cash flow in the early years.
These three notions tell different stories. An investor who looks only at the gross figure is setting up for disappointment.
Step 1: estimate a realistic annual income
The income from a short-term rental always breaks down the same way:
Annual income = nights sold × average price received per night
The number of nights sold depends on your occupancy rate, but also on the periods you deliberately close and on your own personal use. On the Opal Coast, a seafront property concentrates its nights in the warmer months, whereas an urban property in Calais, Dunkirk or Saint-Omer spreads its occupancy better across the year.
The average price received is not your advertised price. Take off:
- the platform commission charged on the host side;
- the discounts you grant (long stay, last minute, early booking);
- nights given free as a goodwill gesture.
Add, on the other hand, the cleaning fees you recharge, which are income — provided you put the corresponding expense on the right side of the table.
For a first estimate, base yourself on comparable listings actually booked in your commune, not on prices advertised at the height of the season. Then take a cautious assumption: better to be pleasantly surprised.
Step 2: list every cost
This is the step where people go wrong most often, by omission. Here is the list we use.
| Item | Nature | Order of magnitude seen in the market |
|---|---|---|
| Platform commission | Variable | A few per cent of rents, host side |
| Cleaning and linen | Variable | The main item after management |
| Concierge service, full management | Variable | Generally 15 to 25% of rents including tax |
| Energy, water, internet | Semi-fixed | Higher than in long-term letting |
| Non-occupying owner and liability insurance | Fixed | Annual |
| Property tax | Fixed | Annual |
| Business property tax | Fixed | Depending on commune and situation |
| Service charges | Fixed | Annual |
| Consumables and small equipment | Variable | Products, bulbs, crockery |
| Upkeep and replacement | Provision | Set aside every year |
| Accountancy | Fixed | If on the actual-expenses scheme |
Two items are almost always underestimated. The first is replacing furniture and linen: in short-term letting, bedding, a sofa or a set of pans wear out far faster than in conventional letting. The second is the provision for works and unforeseen events, which must exist even in years without incident.
Step 3: apply the formula
Once the two columns are filled in, the calculation is simple.
Net yield = (annual income − annual costs) ÷ total acquisition cost × 100
The total acquisition cost covers the price of the property, notary fees, any agency fees, the cost of works and the furnishing budget. Many investors forget the furnishing, which nonetheless represents a real sum in a fully equipped furnished holiday let.
Take a deliberately simplified illustration, with made-up figures to be replaced by your own. A property acquired for €150,000 all fees included, generating €18,000 in annual income and bearing €8,000 of costs, produces €10,000 of operating profit, or a net yield of around 6.7%. The same property with only €12,000 of income falls to around 2.7%. The difference does not come from the purchase price: it comes from occupancy and from keeping costs under control.
Step 4: factor in tax and financing
Net operating yield remains a pre-tax indicator. To know your real gain, you have to go one level down.
On tax, the applicable scheme changes the result substantially. Under the micro-BIC, a flat-rate allowance applies to your income, with different rates and ceilings depending on whether your furnished holiday let is classified or not. Under the régime réel, you deduct your actual costs and claim depreciation. The choice is not a trivial one and depends on your personal situation — always have the decision validated by an accountant.
On financing, subtract your loan repayment from your operating profit to obtain pre-tax cash flow. Then subtract estimated tax and social levies to obtain net cash flow. That is the figure which determines whether your investment finances itself.
The items people systematically forget
- Blank nights for putting things right. A day blocked between two stays for a deep clean or a repair is a night not sold.
- The time you spend on it. If you manage alone, put a value on your hours: answering messages, coordinating, trips back and forth for key handovers. Five hours a week is not free.
- Cancellations. They happen, and rarely at a convenient moment.
- Forced upgrading. The market is professionalising: staying competitive means reinvesting in the property regularly.
The four indicators to track month by month
An annual calculation is not enough to steer a property. Four figures, recorded each month in a simple spreadsheet, warn you of drift long before the year-end accounts.
- The occupancy rate, calculated on nights genuinely available for sale, excluding periods of your own use.
- The average price received per night sold, net of commission and discounts. This is what reveals a pricing policy that is too soft.
- Revenue per available night, which combines the previous two and is the best overall performance indicator.
- Average cost per stay, cleaning, linen and consumables included. A run of one-night stays can send this item soaring without turnover moving at all.
Compare each month with the same month the previous year, never with the month before: on the Opal Coast, seasonality would make the comparison meaningless. A February is judged against a February, not against a January.
Should you delegate to improve profitability?
The question comes up at every simulation. A concierge service represents an additional cost, generally between 15% and 25% of rents including tax for full management, depending on the services chosen. But it also acts on the top line: a better listing, actively managed pricing, responsiveness to requests, stronger reviews — hence more nights sold and a better-held average price.
The right test is to compare two scenarios over twelve months: your current result, and a simulated result with improved occupancy and average price, less the management cost. If the difference is positive, delegation pays for itself.
Finally, keep one simple habit: redo this calculation once a year, in January, on the year just gone rather than on projections. It is the only way to steer your property rather than be steered by it.
We carry out this kind of simulation for owners in Calais, Gravelines, Dunkirk, Saint-Omer and Boulogne-sur-Mer, with no commitment, based on your actual property. If you would like to test your figures against ours, see our rates and services or call us on 06.59.97.61.29.
Frequently asked questions
What profitability should you aim for in short-term letting? There is no universal threshold: it all depends on the purchase price, the town, seasonality and how much you delegate. What matters is comparing your net yield, after actual costs, with what you would get from conventional letting on the same property, then checking that cash flow remains sustainable in the bad years.
Should cleaning fees count as income or as a cost? Both, each in its proper place. Cleaning fees recharged to the guest are income; the actual cost of the service is an expense. Making them disappear from both columns distorts the calculation and hides any under-charging of cleaning, which is common on single-night stays.
Is the gross yield shown by online calculators reliable? It gives a rough idea, rarely more. These tools often ignore furnishing, replacement provisions, tax and management time. Use them to shortlist properties, then redo the full calculation with your actual costs and have the tax assumptions validated by a professional.